
With a vote of 8-1, the Delaware Health Resources Board denied a Certificate of Public Review for two micro-hospitals proposed by ChristianaCare. The two healthcare facilities would be located in Georgetown and Camden. A public hearing was held on October 20 regarding the proposal. The Georgetown campus would represent $65.1 million and Camden $58.1 million investments by ChristianaCare.
“As you know, Kent and Sussex are places where people are building their lives, raising their families and putting down roots,” Pauline Corso, ChristianaCare Ambulatory Services President, said. And we want healthcare to be there for them as these communities continue to grow. And patients and community members have told us directly they want care close to where they live with less travel and more time with people who depend on them.”
Corso provided statistics that indicated long wait times to see physicians in Kent and Sussex County, an increase in residents who are 65 and older who often need more medical services than younger people, an increase in the need for outpatient services and better access to emergency services over the next five years. Corso provided data that showed long wait times in emergency departments at four southern Delaware hospitals, including Bayhealth Kent, Bayhealth Sussex, TidalHealth and Beebe.
“At the four hospitals shown, median visit times range from 167 minutes to 278 minutes, compared to the national benchmark of 157 minutes,” Corso said. “Also, the number of patients who leave before being seen varies by hospital. For our proposed neighborhood h hospitals, our 90-minute estimate is an internal projection based on performance of top hospitals in other regions.”
Dr. Vinay Maheshwari, Physician Executive for Growth and Strategic Partnerships with ChristianaCare pointed out that his organization looked forward to working with other healthcare agencies in the area to grow medical care throughout Kent and Sussex County.
“These campuses function as a healthcare ecosystem that integrates with the regional infrastructure, which already includes primary care, pediatrics, urgent care and many other subspecialties,” Maheshwari said. “To build a sustainable model, one that allows us to recruit and retain talent to the community, it’s important to note that each of these pieces is complimentary to the other. And ChristianaCare cannot build these individually. This is part of a whole, and it functions only as one whole system. So, we would not be able to, for example, build a Sussex campus and not a Kent campus or vice versa.”
Beebe Healthcare, Bayhealth and TidalHealth opposed the two micro-hospitals during the public hearing. The three medical providers were not opposed to competition from ChrsitianaCare but argued that the type of facility proposed did not meet Delaware law and that the arguments used to support the need were conflated.
“We share a common goal, a healthcare ecosystem in Delaware that is accessible, high quality and sustainable. But we are also tasked with keeping healthcare costs low,” Kyle Benoit, Executive Vice-President and Chief Operating Officer at Bayhealth, said. “We must ask ourselves, do these proposals solve these challenges or do we further lock in the high-cost infrastructure into our healthcare system here in Delaware. Now, proponents of this proposal will tell you it is a convenient option for care close to home, when, in reality, a freestanding ER and eight low-capacity beds are exceptionally high cost for a low-volume benefit to the community.”
Benoit stated that true competition lowers costs, improves access and enhances the population health of the community.
“Delaware families deserve care close to home that they can afford,” Benoit said. “Bayhealth’s position is this: we support investment in Kent County. We support expanded specialty care, primary care, behavioral health and urgent care, none of which require the board’s approval to accomplish. What does require the board’s approval is the eight emergency beds and the eight inpatient beds.”
Benoit acknowledged that there were ER challenges, but Bayhealth, along with the other existing medical facilities, were working to address those.
“ER capacity concerns, the immediate answer should not be more ERS,” Benoit said. “The reality is that the ER and the inpatient are some of the most expensive parts of the healthcare organization, the most difficult to staff, the most high cost to run. And as we continue to focus on lowering cost in the state, it makes no sense to introduce a more high-cost setting into an area already being served.”
Dr. David Tam, CEO of Beebe Healthcare, claimed that the ER statistics presented by ChristianaCare were conflated.
“ED visit time is how long a patient stays in the ER from checking in and getting triaged to either getting discharged or having some kind of disposition, either admission or to a different level of care like behavioral health or skilled nursing facility,” Tam said. “You’ll notice that is different than wait time. You’ll notice that our visit times are indeed high, but the reason is not because we don’t have enough beds. It is because we don’t have enough behavioral healthcare beds. We don’t have enough skilled nursing facility beds. We don’t have other disposition opportunities that other places have, and that is why patients stay longer in the ED.’
Tam pointed out that ChristianaCare actually had long visit times in their own ER and have a left-without-seen percentage of six percent despite the fact they have high levels of inpatient capacity as well as the ability to send patients to facilities in metropolitan areas.
The ownership of the new facilities was also called into question by the three local medical organizations as well as the fact that there was no designation in Delaware law for something called a “micro-hospital.”
“ChristianaCare is in partnership with Emerus, that partnership does exist,” Steve Leonard, President and CEO of TidalHealth said. “Obviously, this neighborhood health campus, that description should not obscure the fact fo what is being proposed and that a for-profit vendor did not choose TidalHealth to partner with. There is a reason they chose ChristianaCare. It’s because they have the highest commercial rates. They have the opportunity to make the most margin. We call that cherry-picking. And really, it leaves the rest of the hospitals having to take care of the more difficult cases while things are skimmed off the top.”
Leonard pointed out that ChristianaCare’s application for a new for-profit limited 24-hour emergency department with very few inpatient beds that will mainly be used for observation would be extremely costly to residents of Kent and Sussex Counties.
“It is also worth highlighting that it does not identify clear Delaware licensure pathway,” Leonard said. “What’s being proposed is the eight inpatient beds and the board is being asked to approve a new neighborhood hospital which may describe a business modal, but it does not answer the regulatory question what is this facility under Delaware law? That question matters because hospital licensure carries requirements designed to protect patients.”
Leonard felt that ChristianaCare should not be able to fund a smaller hospital and then determine after what regulatory requirements apply.
“Before the board approves any additional inpatient capacity, we should know exactly what license applies and whether this model satisfies every requirement of that license,” Leonard said. “If the model does not fit Delaware’s existing hospital framework, and we’ve asked the Attorney General, this is a policy question for Delaware, not something that should be resolved in a single COPR application. Eight beds does not make the regulatory question smaller. The clarity is even more important. Define the hospital, define the license, demonstrate compliance, then consider approval.”
The review board appeared to agree with the sentiments of the three hospital organizations. Board members questioned inconsistencies in data provided by ChristianaCare’s initial application and those presented at the October 20 meeting. They were also concerned about transporting patients who needed higher-level care. The board was tasked with reviewing seven criteria in order to approve the application.
The board voted favorably that ChristianaCare had the financial resources to build and sustain the campuses. However, the board felt that there was not a demonstrated need for the emergency beds, that this type of facility would not be a less costly alternative for local residents and that adding these new facilities could actually increase costs. The board also did not believe the facility would improve regional care quality, that the facilities would not integrate and may duplicate, services already offered and that the micro-hospital model along with its ownership structure did not align with Delaware licensing law.
ChristianaCare President and CEO Jennifer Schwartz was disappointed in the decision and that the organization would carefully review the board’s decision before making a decision on how to move forward. ChristianaCare can appeal the board’s decision or adjust the application to better meet the criteria.
Representative Bryan Shupe announced a few days after the decision that he was re-introducing legislation to repeal Delaware’s Certificate of Public Review.
“When the state makes it harder for providers to expand, patients pay the price” Shupe said. “Less competition puts upward pressure on costs, leaves families with fewer choices and makes it harder to find quality care close to home.”

